top of page

Mikayla's Bookish Star Rating Review Guide

Every reader and person has their own ranking system for various things, including reading and books, which is absolutely great. I'm sharing my rating guide so that anyone who reads my reviews and ratings can get a better grasp of how I evaluate and review books.

A bit of info 

I provide ratings from 1 to 5 stars, including half-star increments, on all review platforms. My book evaluations are categorized into sections: Characters, Atmosphere, Writing, Plot,igue, Logic/Lessons, and Enjoyment. I approach each read with an open mind, jotting down my thoughts on what I like and dislike. After completing the book, I reflect on my notes, assessing elements like character growth, uniqueness, setting detail writing quality, plot consistency, lessons learned, and my overall impressions. I strive to be respectful in my reviews, valuing the diverse perspectives of, editors, publishers, and fellow readers, and celebrating our different tastes and experiences. Books rated 1-2.5 stars not receive reviews on Facebook, Instagram, or Amazon.

1 and 1.5 Ratings

I found that the characters, settings, writing style, and plot of book were either unengaging or inadequately developed, which presented in my reading experience. Ultimately, I struggled to connect with the narrative and did not derive enjoyment from it. Nonetheless, I acknowledge that this is solely my perspective, and it is entirely possible that other readers may appreciate and enjoy the book in a manner that I could not. Consequently, I will refrain from posting reviews of these specific titles on platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, my blog or Amazon, except for brief mentions in my monthly wrap-ups.

Two and 2.5 Star Ratings

The characters, settings, writing style, and plot of the book were indeed enjoyable and showed a moderate level of development. Although I found myself somewhat engaged by the narrative, I must admit that the various flaws and the lack of depth in certain areas overshadow my overall enjoyment of the reading experience. It is important to note that this assessment reflects personal perspective, and it is entirely possible that other readers may find value in the book and appreciate it in ways that I did not. As a result, I have decided to refrain from posting in-depth reviews of these specific titles on social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, as well as on my blog and Amazon. Instead, will include brief mentions of them in my monthly wrap-up posts.

3 and 3.5 Star Ratings

The characters, settings, writing style, and plot of the book offered a notable level of enjoyment that I found commendable. Overall, the book managed to engage interest for the majority of its duration and provided some entertaining moments. However, I did identify several concerns pertaining to the development of characters, the intricacies of the plot, and the overall narrative, which ultimately hindered my ability to fully enjoy the book as I had anticipated. Despite these, I intend to share my insights by posting detailed reviews on various review platforms and would encourage readers to consider giving this book a read at least once.

4 and 4.5 Star Ratings

The characters, settings, writing style, and plot of the book were predominantly enjoyable and well-developed, contributing to a compelling reading experience. I found the book to be quite engaging, as it consistently captured my attention from the beginning to the end. While I did observe a few minor flaws or underdeveloped elements within the plot, character development, or settings that slightly impacted my overall enjoyment, these issues did not significantly detract from the overall of the read. I intend to recommend these books to and will be posting reviews on my review sites, as I believe they merit being read at least once by anyone who appreciates quality literature.

5 Stars Ratings

The characters, settings, writing style, and overall plot of the book were not only engaging but also expertly crafted, offering thoroughly enriching reading experience. From the very first page to the conclusion, the narrative effectively captured my attention and maintained my engagement throughout the entire journey. Although I encountered a few minor flaws that slightly influenced my overall enjoyment, I must stress that these issues not diminish my appreciation for the book; it rightfully stands as one of my favorite reads and has earned a well-deserved five-star rating. I am fully inclined to share my insights and reviews of these exceptional books on various review platforms, and I highly recommend them to fellow readers.

Subscribe to our newsletter • Don’t miss out!

  • Email
  • Amazon
  • BookBub
  • Goodreads
  • online book club
  • Storygraph
  • benable
  • booksirens

© 2024 by Mikayla's Bookish Creatives. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page